“Natural” Does NOT Mean Safe: Watch Out for Supplements

By Sister Mary Sarah Macht, RSM, MSN, FNP-BC

Patients often have questions about what that they can take that is “natural” to help them with their health.  The truth is that most of what we need for health can be gained by eating healthy diet.  While there are many companies selling supplements to promote health, we need to remember that many of these “natural” products can cause many different effects in the body.  Many of these things, such as common spices, are typically safe when eaten food, but can have profound effects on the body and how other medicine is metabolized in the body when taken in high doses.  In other words, taking something “natural” can affect the way other medications work and even make them work differently than intended.[i]

What about Turmeric?

For example, turmeric or curcumin is thought to be a powerful anti-inflammatory medication.[ii]  We know that it can decrease blood sugar levels and affect how the blood clots.  It also interacts with a key pathway in the liver that is used by other medications, meaning that it can interact with of lot of other common prescription drugs.[iii]  There are groups of patients who should probably avoid turmeric altogether.  High doses of turmeric in capsule or pill form can cause significant problems in terms of drug interactions and potentially other effects on the body.[iv]

Who Needs a supplement or vitamin?

Some people, however, do need vitamin supplements.  For example, we know that most people at this high latitude and at this time of the year we will have a low vitamin D levels.  Vitamin D is very important for calcium metabolism and bone health.  Healthcare providers commonly have patients take supplemental vitamin D.  This is important because we know that their bodies are lacking enough vitamin D.  For these individuals, vitamin D can be safely given as a medication to improve their health.  We also know that calcium supplementation is important for some people and there are recommended guidelines to support the dosing.

Supplements Can cause problems with other medications

Unfortunately, there is not a lot of information out there about taking high doses of different vitamins or supplements for good health.  These supplements are often not well studied, nor do we know what a safe dose is.  For some vitamins, the body will just excrete what is not needed.  Others are not gotten rid of so easily and can cause profound changes in the way that the body works and interacts with other medications.

Best Plan: Talk with your health care provider to see if it is safe for you

The best idea, before taking any supplements, including those that you have heard are “natural” or “safe,” is to sit down with your primary care provider or other qualified clinician and look at the proposed remedy to see if it safe for you given your other conditions and other medications.

For more information, see this pamphlet by the National Institutes of Health

Age Page: Dietary Supplements


[i] Sasaki, Takamitsu, Yu Sato, Takeshi Kumagai, Kouichi Yoshinari, and Kiyoshi Nagata. “Effect of Health Foods on Cytochrome P450-Mediated Drug Metabolism.” Journal of Pharmaceutical Health Care and Sciences 3, no. 1 (May 10, 2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40780-017-0083-x.

[ii] “Turmeric: Health Benefits, Uses, Side Effects, Dosage & Interactions.” RxList. RxList, September 17, 2019. https://www.rxlist.com/turmeric/supplements.htm.

[iii] Rosengren, Rhonda J, and Shuli Chen. “Modulation of Hepatic Drug Metabolizing Enzymes by the Natural Polyphenol Curcumin.” Internal medicine review, November 2017. http://dx.doi.org/10.18103/imr.v3i11.631.

[iv] Cox, Lauren. “What Is Turmeric?” LiveScience. Future US, November 16, 2017. https://www.livescience.com/41760-turmeric-supplement-facts.html.

Posted January 11, 2021

To Gather into One All the Scattered Children of God

To Gather into One All the Scattered Children of God

Lessons from the Desert

Lessons from the Desert

World Day Of The Sick 2024: Healing the Sick by Healing Relationships

World Day Of The Sick 2024: Healing the Sick by Healing Relationships

Finding Bethany Beyond the Jordan

Finding Bethany Beyond the Jordan

Focus on Catholic Health Care

Focus on Catholic Health Care

Celebrating His Presence With Us

Celebrating His Presence With Us

New Opportunities for Authentic Health Care at Sacred Heart

New Opportunities for Authentic Health Care at Sacred Heart

Jesus Called Us While We Were Perishing

Jesus Called Us While We Were Perishing

“Brain Death”: Could the Whole Medico-Legal Establishment  have been Wrong for 55 Years?

“Brain Death”: Could the Whole Medico-Legal Establishment have been Wrong for 55 Years?

A Hymn of Mary Magdalene: Lord, Show us Your Face

A Hymn of Mary Magdalene: Lord, Show us Your Face

What Women Wish They had Learned about Their Bodies

What Women Wish They had Learned about Their Bodies

Which TICKS Can Make Me Sick?

Which TICKS Can Make Me Sick?

An Abyss of Love to Meet Our Every Need

An Abyss of Love to Meet Our Every Need

He was Known in the Breaking of the Bread

He was Known in the Breaking of the Bread

And All Who Touched His Hem were Healed

And All Who Touched His Hem were Healed

Healthcare Focused on the Family

Healthcare Focused on the Family

The Call of Wisdom

The Call of Wisdom

Catholic Identity in Action

Catholic Identity in Action

Serving God’s Children

Serving God’s Children

I See the Face of Christ in Them

I See the Face of Christ in Them

The Promise of Eternal Happiness

The Promise of Eternal Happiness

Advent: Watching with Lamps Alight

Advent: Watching with Lamps Alight

The Sisters of Mercy in the Crimean War: Lessons for Catholic health care

The Sisters of Mercy in the Crimean War: Lessons for Catholic health care

Eating with Tax Collectors and Sinners

Eating with Tax Collectors and Sinners